Getting Independent KiwiSaver Advice in NZ

Getting Independent KiwiSaver Advice in New Zealand

With over 3 million New Zealanders enrolled in KiwiSaver and more than 30 providers to choose from, getting quality guidance on your KiwiSaver can make a significant difference to your retirement outcome. But not all guidance is created equal.

This guide explains what makes KiwiSaver guidance truly independent, how to find unbiased sources of information, and the key questions to ask potential advisers.

Disclaimer: This is general information only. Seek guidance from a licensed financial adviser for your specific situation.

---

What Makes Guidance "Independent"?

True Independence Defined

Independent KiwiSaver guidance means the person helping you:

1. Has no financial ties to any KiwiSaver provider
2. Can access all providers in the market
3. Receives no commissions from KiwiSaver schemes
4. Has no sales targets or volume requirements
5. Is paid by you (the client) or operates without commercial interest

The Independence Spectrum

Not all guidance is equally independent. Here's a spectrum:

LevelDescriptionExampleFully IndependentNo provider relationships, paid by clientFee-only adviserBroadly IndependentAccess to most providers, may receive small feesPlatform-based advisersLimited IndependenceAccess to several providers, receives commissionsSome financial advisersProvider-AlignedEmployed by or contracted to specific providerBank advisers, provider staffConflictedDirect financial benefit from recommendationsSales staff with targets

Why Independence Matters for KiwiSaver

The stakes are high:

• KiwiSaver will likely be your largest financial asset after your home
• Small differences in fees compound dramatically over decades
• Fund choice can mean hundreds of thousands of dollars difference
• Poor guidance early on affects your entire working life

Example: Impact of 0.5% Higher Fees

Starting balance: $20,000 Annual contributions: $5,000 Investment period: 30 years Return before fees: 7%

Fee LevelFinal BalanceDifference0.5% fees$892,000Baseline1.0% fees$798,000-$94,0001.5% fees$715,000-$177,000

A non-independent adviser steering you to a higher-fee fund could cost you significant amounts over a working life.

---

Types of KiwiSaver Guidance Available

1. Provider-Employed Staff

Who they are:

• Work directly for a KiwiSaver provider
• May be at banks, insurance companies, or fund managers
• Often available at no direct cost

Limitations:

• Can only discuss their employer's products
• May have sales targets or incentives
• Cannot compare with competitors
• Primary loyalty is to employer

When appropriate:

• You've already chosen the provider
• You want help with that specific scheme's options
• You understand they can only discuss their products

2. Bank-Based Advisers

Who they are:

• Employed by major banks (ANZ, ASB, BNZ, Westpac, Kiwibank)
• Usually access only bank-owned KiwiSaver scheme
• Available to bank customers

Limitations:

• Banks own their own KiwiSaver schemes
• Strong incentive to keep you in their scheme
• Limited view of wider market
• May be generalists, not KiwiSaver specialists

When appropriate:

• You're happy with your bank's scheme
• You want convenient, free guidance
• You understand the limitations

3. Commission-Based Financial Advisers

Who they are:

• Licensed financial advisers
• May receive trailing commissions from KiwiSaver providers
• Can typically access multiple providers

Considerations:

• Commissions create potential conflicts
• May favour schemes that pay higher commissions
• Quality and independence varies significantly
• Must disclose commission arrangements

When appropriate:

• You want broader market access than bank advisers
• You can't afford fee-only guidance
• You carefully review their disclosure statement

4. Fee-Only Financial Advisers

Who they are:

• Charge you directly for guidance
• No commissions from KiwiSaver providers
• Can access all schemes in market

Advantages:

• Truly objective guidance
• No conflicts of interest
• Will consider low-cost passive options
• Focus on your interests only

Considerations:

• Costs typically $300-$1,500 for KiwiSaver review
• Need to pay regardless of outcome
• May be harder to find

When appropriate:

• You want genuinely independent analysis
• Your balance justifies the fee
• You value objectivity over convenience

5. Robo-Advisers and Online Tools

Who they are:

• Digital platforms providing automated guidance
• Use algorithms to suggest fund types
• Examples: Sorted.org.nz (government), some fintech tools

Advantages:

• No human bias
• Often free
• Quick and convenient
• Based on standard methodology

Limitations:

• Cannot understand nuanced situations
• Generic guidance only
• No ongoing relationship
• May not consider all factors

When appropriate:

• You have straightforward needs
• You want a starting point
• You'll verify results with other sources

---

How to Find Independent KiwiSaver Guidance

Step 1: Clarify What You Need

Basic needs:

• Which fund type suits your age and risk tolerance
• Whether your current scheme is competitive
• How much you should contribute

Complex needs:

• Tax efficiency for different situations
• First home withdrawal planning
• Retirement income projections
• Coordinating KiwiSaver with other investments

Step 2: Identify Truly Independent Sources

Government resources (free, no conflicts):

• Sorted.org.nz: Government-funded, independent tools and information
• FMA website: Regulatory information, provider comparisons
• IRD website: Tax and contribution information

Fee-only advisers:

• Search for advisers who explicitly state "fee-only"
• Ask directly: "Do you receive any payments from KiwiSaver providers?"
• Check their disclosure statement

Not-for-profit organisations:

• Citizens Advice Bureau (general guidance)
• Community law centres (specific situations)
• Some iwi-based financial capability services

Step 3: Verify Independence Claims

Ask these direct questions:

1. "Do you receive any commissions or fees from KiwiSaver providers?"
2. "How many different KiwiSaver schemes can you access?"
3. "What financial relationship, if any, do you have with KiwiSaver providers?"
4. "Are you employed by or contracted to any provider?"
5. "Can I see your disclosure statement?"

Check responses against disclosure:

• Disclosure statement must detail all remuneration
• Look for "commission," "trail," or "referral fees"
• Check for volume bonuses or incentives

Step 4: Use Multiple Sources

Triangulation approach:

1. Start with free resources (Sorted.org.nz)
2. Cross-check with provider tools (several schemes have comparison tools)
3. Verify with independent adviser if needed
4. Make your own informed decision

---

Questions to Ask Potential KiwiSaver Advisers

About Their Independence

1. "How are you paid for KiwiSaver guidance?"

- Direct fee = more independent - Commission from providers = potential conflict

1. "Do you receive any ongoing payments related to my KiwiSaver?"

- Trail commissions create ongoing conflicts - Fee-only means no ongoing provider payments

1. "How many KiwiSaver schemes can you access?"

- Full market access = more independent - Limited panel = potential restrictions

1. "What's your relationship with [specific provider name]?"

- Ask about any provider they seem to favour - Look for financial or employment ties

1. "If I chose a scheme that doesn't pay you, would that change anything?"

- Tests whether commission affects their approach - Truly independent advisers won't care

About Their Expertise

1. "How many KiwiSaver reviews have you done?"

- Experience matters - Ask about situations similar to yours

1. "What qualifications do you have relating to KiwiSaver?"

- Minimum: Level 5 NZ Certificate in Financial Services - Better: CFP, degree in finance, specific KiwiSaver training

1. "How do you stay current with KiwiSaver changes?"

- Rules change frequently - Good advisers have ongoing education

1. "Can you explain your process for comparing schemes?"

- Should consider fees, returns, service, fund options - Beware of oversimplified approaches

1. "What information will you need from me?"

- Good process requires understanding your situation - Quick guidance without questions is superficial

About Their Process

1. "Will you provide written documentation of your guidance?"

- Important for accountability - Useful for future reference

1. "What happens after our initial meeting?"

- Implementation support? - Ongoing reviews? - Additional fees?

1. "How do you handle it if we disagree?"

- Tests client-centricity - Remember that final decisions are always yours to make

---

Benefits of Independent vs Provider-Aligned Guidance

Independent Guidance Benefits

Objectivity:

• No pressure to favour any scheme
• Can highlight genuinely competitive options
• Will mention low-cost providers that don't pay commissions

Comprehensive analysis:

• Considers all 30+ KiwiSaver providers
• Compares fees, returns, and features objectively
• Identifies schemes that suit your specific situation

Long-term focus:

• No incentive to switch you unnecessarily
• Focuses on your retirement outcome
• Considers lifetime impact of decisions

Conflict-free:

• Sole duty is to you
• No divided loyalties
• Transparent about any limitations

Provider-Aligned Guidance Limitations

Restricted view:

• Only knows their own products well
• May not mention competitor advantages
• Limited perspective on market

Potential conflicts:

• Employment depends on provider success
• May have sales targets
• Career incentives may not align with your interests

Switching resistance:

• Natural reluctance to help you leave
• May overstate benefits of staying
• May understate competitor strengths

---

Red Flags When Seeking KiwiSaver Guidance

Warning Signs

Pressure tactics:

• Urgency to switch immediately
• Limited-time offers
• Discouraging you from checking alternatives

Lack of transparency:

• Reluctant to explain how they're paid
• Vague about provider relationships
• Won't provide disclosure statement

One-size-fits-all:

• Same solution for everyone
• No questions about your situation
• Generic guidance without personalisation

Complexity theatre:

• Making simple decisions seem impossibly complex
• Creating dependency on their ongoing services
• Suggesting frequent changes

Product pushing:

• Focus on specific schemes rather than your needs
• Dismissive of low-cost options
• Reluctance to discuss passive/index funds

Questions That Should Raise Concerns

If an adviser responds poorly to these questions, reconsider:

• "What schemes don't you have access to?"
• "When did you last suggest a client stay with their current scheme?"
• "What are the lowest-fee options you'd consider?"
• "Can I take time to think about this?"

---

Making the Most of Independent Guidance

Before Your Meeting

1. Gather information:

- Current scheme name and fund type - Current balance and contribution rate - Investment time horizon - Risk tolerance (how would you feel if balance dropped 20%?)

1. Define your questions:

- What specifically do you want to know? - What decisions are you trying to make? - What concerns do you have?

1. Research basics:

- Use Sorted.org.nz to understand fund types - Know the general fee ranges - Understand contribution rules

During Your Meeting

1. Verify independence:

- Ask the direct questions listed above - Request disclosure statement - Clarify any concerns

1. Take notes:

- Document key points - Record specific scheme names mentioned - Note any caveats or limitations

1. Ask "why":

- Understand reasoning behind suggestions - Challenge anything unclear - Request evidence for claims

After Your Meeting

1. Verify independently:

- Check facts using official sources - Compare with Sorted.org.nz recommendations - Review scheme details yourself

1. Take time:

- Don't rush decisions - Consider alternatives - Seek second opinion if uncertain

1. Document your decision:

- Record why you chose particular option - Keep guidance received - Set reminder for future review

---

Summary: Finding Independent KiwiSaver Guidance

Your Options

SourceIndependenceCostSuitabilitySorted.org.nzHighFreeGeneral guidanceFee-only advisersHigh$300-$1,500Personalised analysisCommission advisersVariesFree/LowCheck disclosure carefullyBank advisersLowFreeTheir scheme onlyProvider staffLowFreeExisting scheme questions

Key Takeaways

1. True independence is rare - Most free guidance has some conflict
2. Disclosure is required - Always review the disclosure statement
3. Use multiple sources - Don't rely on any single opinion
4. Government resources are neutral - Sorted.org.nz has no conflicts
5. Consider paying for objectivity - Fee-only guidance eliminates conflicts
6. Your decision matters - Small differences compound over decades

Action Steps

1. Start with Sorted.org.nz for free, independent basics
2. Identify your specific needs and questions
3. If seeking an adviser, verify their independence carefully
4. Ask the tough questions about how they're paid
5. Take time to make your decision
6. Review your KiwiSaver annually

Disclaimer: This is general information only. Seek guidance from a licensed financial adviser for your specific situation.